Vantage and Golden, the pause pushed to November, Amazon drops GW campus data centers, Quantum Park denied, and SCC staff on the merger
Golden Substation vote moved to Tomorrow
The Board of Supervisors moved its vote on Dominion's Golden Substation from Dec. 1 to tomorrow, Thursday, Nov. 5. Public comment and the vote are at 6 p.m. in Leesburg.
Golden is Dominion's 500 kV substation on Pacific Boulevard in Sterling, next to the W&OD Trail. It is one end of the Golden-to-Mars line. The Board has deferred it twice, most recently in September, because the design wasn't good enough. Dominion has not come back with any real changes. It tried to wait it out, then pulled a bargaining chip out of its back pocket. Another back-room deal was done with Dominion and Vantage, and the vote moved up a month.
In September, the Board sent Dominion a clear message. As the Board voted to defer, Supervisor Koran Saines, Golden's own district supervisor, said: "By forwarding to December, again, this is going to show Dominion that we're not playing, that you guys can do better, should do better with your designs, and you can start with this one."
Where did that go? What changed?
We are asking the Board to defer Golden and still demand a fix for Vantage 2.
Please email the Board at bos@loudoun.gov before Thursday, and come to the meeting at 6 p.m. in Leesburg. Details are below.
Questions about the Vantage deal

On Oct. 20, the Board voted to bring Golden back early. Loudoun Now reported the limited terms that are public:
Dominion will provide "a portion" of Vantage 2's power by the end of 2028, so the gas turbines can come out.
Vantage will shift some power from another campus.
Vantage 2's full grid connection still waits in Dominion's queue.
No written agreement has been made public. There is no clarity. The community has been told nothing about how much power is involved or what the deal actually entails. Instead, there is another far-off date: the end of 2028. What if Dominion moves that date, like it has so many other times? What happens with Golden then? Set aside that these trades shouldn't happen at all. Who gives up their side before there are guarantees with real teeth on the other? It is deal making 101.
To say Vantage 2 has been awful for the people who live around it would be an understatement. Its gas turbines run 24/7 as the campus's main power, next to homes. The turbines were added after the Board approved the project, and supervisors didn't know they were coming. The state approved the gas plant without public input. What kind of community partner or neighbor is that?
One neighbor says you can hear the turbines through your house at 3 a.m.
In July, a failure at the on-site power plant left the campus running diesel generators for nearly 24 hours, and one resident left his home.
A Harvard-affiliated study found that at the pollution levels its permit allows, the plant could cause $53 million to $99 million a year in health damage and 3.4 to 6.5 premature deaths a year, or 17 to 33 over five years. More than 2.5 million people live where the study found the pollution would rise, with Sterling hit hardest.
Congressman Subramanyam says he hears more complaints about Vantage than any other facility. In August, Vantage said it would not get a grid connection until 2040.
Golden and Vantage were never directly linked until this deal. No project should be traded for the other. No community should be traded for the other.
Dominion says the Vantage fix is tied to Golden. Its spokesperson said the change in timing "reflects the ability to provide certainty around the in-service date identified by PJM and ordered by the SCC," "enabling the temporary bridging solution to move forward."
Supporters of the deal say approving Golden can get Vantage on the grid years early.
So Dominion is now selling Golden, at least in part, as a way to power a data center.
In May, Dominion told the county its projects "were not driven by, and do not provide service to any particular customer."
At the Planning Commission, Jack Story, speaking for Dominion, said Golden itself is not meant to serve any specific customer. Which is it? And if the Vantage fix depends on Golden's date, it depends on the kind of date Dominion has already moved on other projects.
If Vantage gets power years ahead of 2040 because of this deal, something else has to move to make room. What is it, and who gives it up? And if Dominion can move something to make this work, why can't it move it anyway, without trading Golden for it? Nobody is answering that question.
Golden-to-Mars and the Supreme Court appeals
The School Board, Loudoun Valley Estates and the County have all appealed the SCC's Golden-to-Mars approval to the Virginia Supreme Court.
Golden is one end of that line. In its Oct. 27 petition, the County argues the SCC was wrong to reject underground lines based on an "urgent reliability need" that "depended on load from uncommitted, speculative, or nonexistent potential delivery points."
That is the County's own argument. The Board of Supervisors' argument.
The Board should hold Dominion to the same standard on Golden before it votes. How much load does Golden serve? When is it actually needed? What connects to it? Dominion has never given a straight answer. The Board can't weigh urgency against land use without that information.
Dominion's deadlines on other projects
Dominion says Golden is "critically important" and on a critical timeline that gets harder to meet with each deferral. In July, Dominion told the Board it was "minutes away" from putting every Ashburn data center on generators.
Wishing Star to Mars: PJM required it by June 1, 2025, an "immediate need." Dominion ruled out undergrounding partly because it couldn't be in service by summer 2025. Then it asked the SCC to move part of the project to June 30, 2026.
Aspen, Golden and Golden to Mars, which PJM calls the "Data Center Alley Local Solution": PJM's required in-service date was June 2027. Dominion's own projected date was June 2028, a year late before anything was filed.
Valley Link is the clearest case. In Orange County in March, Dominion's Greg Mathe, speaking for Valley Link, said it plainly:
"The violations that PJM identified in 2029 are non-negotiable. We have to solve those."
- Greg Mathe, Director, Electric Transmission Engagement, Permitting & Land at Dominion Energy
Dominion and Valley Link told Orange County that having the line in service by the end of 2029 was non-negotiable.
On Nov. 3, Loudoun Now reported that Valley Link has pushed its in-service date to May 31, 2031, about 18 months later.
I guess it was negotiable.
This looks like Dominion's standard process.
First it says undergrounding isn't possible. When it turns out it is possible, it says there isn't time. Then its own timeline slips anyway, and that doesn't seem to matter. It has done this on every project in the Loudoun loop.
On Wishing Star to Mars, Aspen to Golden and Golden to Mars, it ruled out undergrounding at least in part because it said an underground line couldn't be in service in time.
Aspen to Golden is taking longer. Golden to Mars will take longer too.
Either Dominion knows this, or it is bad at its job.
We have to be very skeptical of everything presented to us as a "fact." Too many times now, what we were told was a fact has turned out not to be true.
On Golden-to-Mars, Dominion said burying part of the line would take too long: about 45 months, 18 months past its June 2028 date. The SCC used that as one reason to reject undergrounding. But by Dominion's own estimate, the overhead line takes about 30 months from the SCC's June 29, 2026 order. That is the end of 2028, already past June 2028. And Dominion waited until March 2025 to file, 15 months after PJM approved the project.
With the pushback it faces, Dominion knows the overhead line could take longer than that. It just doesn't want to bury the line, or put it where industrial infrastructure belongs.
If Dominion had done this right from the start, it could be building by now. Instead, the overhead route is tied up at the Virginia Supreme Court, and that fight could run well past June 2028. Anyone planning a project like this would expect that fight and build in time for it.
Dominion's own employee, speaking for Valley Link in Orange County, said: "From an engineering standpoint, with enough money, most things are possible."
In Loudoun, a FirstEnergy spokesperson for the Valley Link project told the Loudoun Times-Mirror, "Building the line underground is not a practical option." Doing it right is possible. Dominion's own people say so. Dominion just isn't willing.
Every delay costs everyone more. Communities pay in livability, and in what it takes to fight for these projects to be done the right way. Data centers lose revenue while they wait for power. Dominion's costs go up too, and it passes them on to ratepayers.
These projects are for data centers. At least everyone agrees on that now, even Dominion. It took Dominion a long time, kicking and screaming, to admit that basic fact. In June 2023, Dominion's Rob Richardson told its own Loudoun community engagement group that none of its projects were for one customer or data center. Now the costs can be assigned to the high-wattage users, the data centers. They can contribute their true fair share. The cost is a blip compared to the revenue from the customers these lines serve. They should pay for the infrastructure they are monetizing. The people in the way shouldn't, either in hard cash or in the disruption to their quality of life. That is not right when there are better ways.
The overhead line along Route 3A will face delays too, maybe years. Dominion knows that. If the need is truly this urgent, why isn't Dominion working toward the fastest route? It can assign the costs to the data centers, and its own team says most things are possible. It wants to do it its way, without regard for this community, instead of doing it the right way. That shows up in case after case. Dominion has spent more effort fighting better solutions than building them.
It took our congressman digging in to get the truth. He had been told that a Golden-to-Mars route along Route 606 wasn't possible because NOAA would object. Then he met with NOAA's administrator and learned NOAA had no technical objection to a route on its land. In these legal proceedings, Dominion sure managed the truth.
Across Virginia
Watch the proceedings in Orange, Louisa and other counties, and you hear outrage, from residents and from local officials who point directly at Loudoun and our leadership. Loudoun is the most mature data center market in the world, and it is time for us to lead.
What about the working group?
This spring, the Board created an Electrical Infrastructure Working Group with Dominion, the data center industry, county staff and residents, to work through exactly this kind of question: substation design and community impact. Board members asked for routine updates and transparency. Since the press release announcing it, the group has done little, and it has been dormant since the summer. This deal didn't go through the working group.
What the Board should do
Defer Golden.
Dominion has had years to plan for Golden, and it paid $90 million for the land. The Board sent the design back in September. Dominion came back with a deal for Vantage instead of a better design. It is impossible not to see what is happening. This is a political solution, not good governance. The land-use reason to defer still stands until Dominion gets it right.
Fix Vantage 2. Full stop.
The neighbors in Sterling should not have to wait on Golden, or on anything else, to get relief. Dominion and Vantage should put the fix in writing: how much power, by when, and what happens if a date slips. The Board should hold them to it. We stand with the Vantage 2 neighbors, and we will push for their fix as hard as we push on Golden.
Why this matters to you
Whether or not you live next to one of these projects, they are all connected. Every data center approved in eastern Loudoun helps drive Valley Link in western Loudoun. A data center in Ashburn drives a substation in Leesburg.
The precedent counts too. How the county handles each project, and what our neighbors are left to live with, affects all of us, in every part of Loudoun.
Each one sets the standard for the next data center and how it gets powered. There will be more. What matters is how those projects get built, and what they do to all of us.
How to take part Thursday
Email the Board before Thursday at bos@loudoun.gov, or leave a voicemail at 703-777-0115. Ask them to defer Golden and keep the Vantage fix separate.
To speak, call 703-777-0200 to sign up by noon Thursday, in person or by phone. You can also sign up with the clerk 30 minutes before the meeting.
Come anyway. Public comment is at 6 p.m. in the Board Room, Loudoun County Government Center, 1 Harrison St. SE, Leesburg. You don't have to speak. Dominion and industry speakers will be there, and residents need to be there too.
Can't make it: watch live at loudoun.gov/meetings.
What's next
Thursday, Nov. 5, 6 p.m.: Golden Substation
Nov. 17: The Board takes up the pause on new data center and substation applications, which matters for the large data center complex proposed at Loudoun County Parkway and Evergreen Mills Road. We need the community's support. The room will be filled with paid speakers from the industry. The industry deserves a voice. We all do. But we cannot allow our voice to be drowned out.
Please forward this to your neighbors.
More updates
Sometimes you win, sometimes they defer